Rob Thomas, 'Cradlesong'

Release date: June 30, 2009
Record label: Emblem/Atlantic
Official Web site: http://www.robthomasmusic.com/

The buzz: Early word on this, Matchbox Twenty frontman Rob Thomas’ sophomore solo effort, was that he was trying to do a “newer version of ‘The Rhythm of the Saints,’” Paul Simon’s classic world music–influenced album. That concept seems to have been quickly abandoned for what the “Smooth” pop-rock singer admits is pretty much just his “usual mish-mosh of styles.” Given that Thomas’ first solo record debuted at No. 1, this conservative approach could be deemed a prudent career choice…if properly executed.

The verdict: It’s not that “Cradlesongs” is terrible, it’s just exceedingly bland. When he’s in his element, like on the up-tempo lead single “Her Diamonds” and slinky rock of “Still Ain’t Over You, ” Thomas remains pleasant enough for a big time pop-rock artist, but ultimately he’s coming off as prematurely dated and disappointingly set on coasting. The 37-year-old’s mostly minor attempts at mixing up his well-worn style—such as on the slightly electro-fied “Gasoline” and “Give Me the Meltdown” or the horn-driven “Wonderful”—sound more embarrassing than interesting. Expect nearly all of these songs to signal “bathroom break” for concertgoers on Thomas’ next tour.

Did you know? The video for “Her Diamonds” features “Clueless” actress Alicia Silverstone, who got her big break thanks to a starring role in the 1993 clip for Aerosmith’s “Cryin’.”